El grupo al cual envías entradas es un grupo Usenet. Si envías mensajes a este grupo, cualquier usuario de Internet podrá ver tu dirección de correo electrónico
gfretw...@aol.com wrote: > On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 19:05:39 -0500, "cshenk" <cshe...@cox.net> wrote:
>> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
> gfretw...@aol.com wrote: > > On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 19:05:39 -0500, "cshenk" <cshe...@cox.net> wrote:
> >> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> > Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
> That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few > short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly > less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 > others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 > block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not > living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble > over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace > some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's > asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and > will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the > originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
> BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there > before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a > ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water > pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be > some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they > want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
Lee-
Fix the easy / cheap ones.
The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson; turn off the power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. Running a ground wire to the nearest water pipe is pretty much a hack solution. My suggestion; if no ground at box, install & "sticker" the GFI.
Negotiate some dollars to be held in the escrow acct to pay for some of the disputed items (chimney waterproofing & sidewalk removal) ...don't want to be fixing the laundry list prior to sale & have the buyer back out.
DD_BobK wrote: > On Nov 1, 7:08 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: >> AZ Nomad wrote: >>> On Sun, 01 Nov 2009 13:24:53 -0500, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: >>>> (I'm clueless about electricity... actually it sort of scares me, so >>>> this is all Greek to me). >>>> Question - I'm in the process of selling an older(1950's) home. The home >>>> inspection was Friday, and I got the buyers' laundry list Saturday >>>> afternoon. One of the things they are asking for is GFCI's to be >>>> installed in the bathrooms. (This is in Baltimore County, if that makes >>> Damn, you're a cheapskate. >> You haven't seen the rest of the laundry list...
>> Seriously when I posted the question, I had no idea if having a GFIC >> installed was a big deal or not. A relative had just told me that since >> it was a two hole plug, the electrician would have to run additional >> wiring from the basement that could cost thousands. If it really is as >> seemingly straightforward as it's been made to sound, I don't mind >> paying for that.
>> What amazes me is that this is the second home inspection in the last >> year, after the prev sale fell through. And both inspectors found >> entirely different things to complain about. The first one never >> mentioned GFCIs, but came up with things like the length of some exhaust >> pipe on the water heater. This one came up with the GFCIs but not the >> plumbing, plus he zeroed in on settlement cracks on the back porch that >> the first one didn't mention as a problem. That's why I was having >> problems evaluating what's really necessary. Versus "oh let's see if we >> can get her to upgrade this while we're at it".
> Your relative is incorrect....are they a contractor, electrician, > engineer or a DIY's that knows anything? > GFI's can be installed without a ground, they come with stickers "no > equipment ground"
> Inspectors justify their fee & cover their butts by finding > "defects"....makes the buyer think they're getting their money;s > worth.
> Be cooperative, preserve the sale but dont give away the farm. > Discuss the list with your realtor & a person knowledgeable as to the > cost of each item ...have your realtor make the list go away.
> cheers > Bob
I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that doesn't.
hall...@aol.com wrote: > On Nov 2, 9:11 am, bud-- <remove.budn...@isp.com> wrote: >> teabird wrote: >>> On Nov 2, 1:40 am, DD_BobK <rkaza...@gmail.com> wrote: >>>> On Nov 1, 7:08 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: >>>>> AZ Nomad wrote: >>>>>> On Sun, 01 Nov 2009 13:24:53 -0500, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: >>>>>>> (I'm clueless about electricity... actually it sort of scares me, so >>>>>>> this is all Greek to me). >>>>>>> Question - I'm in the process of selling an older(1950's) home. The home >>>>>>> inspection was Friday, and I got the buyers' laundry list Saturday >>>>>>> afternoon. One of the things they are asking for is GFCI's to be >>>>>>> installed in the bathrooms. (This is in Baltimore County, if that makes >>>>>> Damn, you're a cheapskate. >>>>> You haven't seen the rest of the laundry list... >>>>> Seriously when I posted the question, I had no idea if having a GFIC >>>>> installed was a big deal or not. A relative had just told me that since >>>>> it was a two hole plug, the electrician would have to run additional >>>>> wiring from the basement that could cost thousands. If it really is as >>>>> seemingly straightforward as it's been made to sound, I don't mind >>>>> paying for that. >>>>> What amazes me is that this is the second home inspection in the last >>>>> year, after the prev sale fell through. And both inspectors found >>>>> entirely different things to complain about. The first one never >>>>> mentioned GFCIs, but came up with things like the length of some exhaust >>>>> pipe on the water heater. This one came up with the GFCIs but not the >>>>> plumbing, plus he zeroed in on settlement cracks on the back porch that >>>>> the first one didn't mention as a problem. That's why I was having >>>>> problems evaluating what's really necessary. Versus "oh let's see if we >>>>> can get her to upgrade this while we're at it". >>>> Your relative is incorrect....are they a contractor, electrician, >>>> engineer or a DIY's that knows anything? >>>> GFI's can be installed without a ground, they come with stickers "no >>>> equipment ground" >>>> Inspectors justify their fee & cover their butts by finding >>>> "defects"....makes the buyer think they're getting their money;s >>>> worth. >>>> Be cooperative, preserve the sale but dont give away the farm. >>>> Discuss the list with your realtor & a person knowledgeable as to the >>>> cost of each item ...have your realtor make the list go away. >>>> cheers >>>> Bob >>> I wouldn't say the relative is incorrect. If it is indeed only 2 wire >>> w/out a ground, the correct and safest way (GFCI, right?) to install >>> it is to run wires plus a ground back to a panel or sub panel. All >>> other options are short cuts to save time, money or hassle, which >>> reduce the safety and *expected* working of the GFCI.
>> GFCIs still work when there is no ground. The NEC explicitly allows them >> to be installed when there is no ground, but in that case they have to >> have the label several people have referred to. IMHO RBM's second post >> is the best advice.
>> -- >> bud-- >> - Hide quoted text -
>> - Show quoted text -
The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
> far better to install a ground wire.
> its not a killer expense
Using your Ouija board again?
You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
> The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google > one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use > google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
> > far better to install a ground wire.
> > its not a killer expense
> Using your Ouija board again?
> You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. > And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a > water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
> -- > bud--
And the reason your previously posted replies contained lots of "quoted text" that you failed to "edit" ...might be?
> On Nov 2, 6:02 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> > gfretw...@aol.com wrote: > > > On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 19:05:39 -0500, "cshenk" <cshe...@cox.net> wrote:
> > >> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> > > Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > > > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
> > That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few > > short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly > > less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 > > others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 > > block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not > > living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble > > over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace > > some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's > > asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and > > will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the > > originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
> > BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there > > before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a > > ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water > > pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be > > some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they > > want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
> Lee-
> Fix the easy / cheap ones.
> The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson; turn off the > power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. > Running a ground wire to the nearest water pipe is pretty much a hack > solution. My suggestion; if no ground at box, install & "sticker" the > GFI.
> Negotiate some dollars to be held in the escrow acct to pay for some > of the disputed items (chimney waterproofing & sidewalk > removal) ...don't want to be fixing the laundry list prior to sale & > have the buyer back out.
> cheers > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -
re: "The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent person; turn off the power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. "
That's assuming the GFCI fits in the original box. My house was built in '56 and getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was either difficult or impossible.
> hall...@aol.com wrote: > > On Nov 2, 9:11 am, bud-- <remove.budn...@isp.com> wrote: > >> teabird wrote: > >>> On Nov 2, 1:40 am, DD_BobK <rkaza...@gmail.com> wrote: > >>>> On Nov 1, 7:08 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >>>>> AZ Nomad wrote: > >>>>>> On Sun, 01 Nov 2009 13:24:53 -0500, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >>>>>>> (I'm clueless about electricity... actually it sort of scares me, so > >>>>>>> this is all Greek to me). > >>>>>>> Question - I'm in the process of selling an older(1950's) home. The home > >>>>>>> inspection was Friday, and I got the buyers' laundry list Saturday > >>>>>>> afternoon. One of the things they are asking for is GFCI's to be > >>>>>>> installed in the bathrooms. (This is in Baltimore County, if that makes > >>>>>> Damn, you're a cheapskate. > >>>>> You haven't seen the rest of the laundry list... > >>>>> Seriously when I posted the question, I had no idea if having a GFIC > >>>>> installed was a big deal or not. A relative had just told me that since > >>>>> it was a two hole plug, the electrician would have to run additional > >>>>> wiring from the basement that could cost thousands. If it really is as > >>>>> seemingly straightforward as it's been made to sound, I don't mind > >>>>> paying for that. > >>>>> What amazes me is that this is the second home inspection in the last > >>>>> year, after the prev sale fell through. And both inspectors found > >>>>> entirely different things to complain about. The first one never > >>>>> mentioned GFCIs, but came up with things like the length of some exhaust > >>>>> pipe on the water heater. This one came up with the GFCIs but not the > >>>>> plumbing, plus he zeroed in on settlement cracks on the back porch that > >>>>> the first one didn't mention as a problem. That's why I was having > >>>>> problems evaluating what's really necessary. Versus "oh let's see if we > >>>>> can get her to upgrade this while we're at it". > >>>> Your relative is incorrect....are they a contractor, electrician, > >>>> engineer or a DIY's that knows anything? > >>>> GFI's can be installed without a ground, they come with stickers "no > >>>> equipment ground" > >>>> Inspectors justify their fee & cover their butts by finding > >>>> "defects"....makes the buyer think they're getting their money;s > >>>> worth. > >>>> Be cooperative, preserve the sale but dont give away the farm. > >>>> Discuss the list with your realtor & a person knowledgeable as to the > >>>> cost of each item ...have your realtor make the list go away. > >>>> cheers > >>>> Bob > >>> I wouldn't say the relative is incorrect. If it is indeed only 2 wire > >>> w/out a ground, the correct and safest way (GFCI, right?) to install > >>> it is to run wires plus a ground back to a panel or sub panel. All > >>> other options are short cuts to save time, money or hassle, which > >>> reduce the safety and *expected* working of the GFCI.
> >> GFCIs still work when there is no ground. The NEC explicitly allows them > >> to be installed when there is no ground, but in that case they have to > >> have the label several people have referred to. IMHO RBM's second post > >> is the best advice.
> >> -- > >> bud-- > >> - Hide quoted text -
> >> - Show quoted text -
> The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google > one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use > google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
> > far better to install a ground wire.
> > its not a killer expense
> Using your Ouija board again?
> You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. > And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a > water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
> -- > bud--- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -
most people overestimate the difficulty in fishing wires in walls. and no wherre did i mention attaching it to a water pipe
> hall...@aol.com wrote: > > On Nov 2, 9:11 am, bud-- <remove.budn...@isp.com> wrote: > >> teabird wrote: > >>> On Nov 2, 1:40 am, DD_BobK <rkaza...@gmail.com> wrote: > >>>> On Nov 1, 7:08 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >>>>> AZ Nomad wrote: > >>>>>> On Sun, 01 Nov 2009 13:24:53 -0500, Lee B > >>>>>> <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote: > >>>>>>> (I'm clueless about electricity... actually it sort of scares me, > >>>>>>> so > >>>>>>> this is all Greek to me). > >>>>>>> Question - I'm in the process of selling an older(1950's) home. > >>>>>>> The home > >>>>>>> inspection was Friday, and I got the buyers' laundry list Saturday > >>>>>>> afternoon. One of the things they are asking for is GFCI's to be > >>>>>>> installed in the bathrooms. (This is in Baltimore County, if that > >>>>>>> makes > >>>>>> Damn, you're a cheapskate. > >>>>> You haven't seen the rest of the laundry list... > >>>>> Seriously when I posted the question, I had no idea if having a GFIC > >>>>> installed was a big deal or not. A relative had just told me that > >>>>> since > >>>>> it was a two hole plug, the electrician would have to run additional > >>>>> wiring from the basement that could cost thousands. If it really is > >>>>> as > >>>>> seemingly straightforward as it's been made to sound, I don't mind > >>>>> paying for that. > >>>>> What amazes me is that this is the second home inspection in the > >>>>> last > >>>>> year, after the prev sale fell through. And both inspectors found > >>>>> entirely different things to complain about. The first one never > >>>>> mentioned GFCIs, but came up with things like the length of some > >>>>> exhaust > >>>>> pipe on the water heater. This one came up with the GFCIs but not > >>>>> the > >>>>> plumbing, plus he zeroed in on settlement cracks on the back porch > >>>>> that > >>>>> the first one didn't mention as a problem. That's why I was having > >>>>> problems evaluating what's really necessary. Versus "oh let's see if > >>>>> we > >>>>> can get her to upgrade this while we're at it". > >>>> Your relative is incorrect....are they a contractor, electrician, > >>>> engineer or a DIY's that knows anything? > >>>> GFI's can be installed without a ground, they come with stickers "no > >>>> equipment ground" > >>>> Inspectors justify their fee & cover their butts by finding > >>>> "defects"....makes the buyer think they're getting their money;s > >>>> worth. > >>>> Be cooperative, preserve the sale but dont give away the farm. > >>>> Discuss the list with your realtor & a person knowledgeable as to the > >>>> cost of each item ...have your realtor make the list go away. > >>>> cheers > >>>> Bob > >>> I wouldn't say the relative is incorrect. If it is indeed only 2 wire > >>> w/out a ground, the correct and safest way (GFCI, right?) to install > >>> it is to run wires plus a ground back to a panel or sub panel. All > >>> other options are short cuts to save time, money or hassle, which > >>> reduce the safety and *expected* working of the GFCI.
> >> GFCIs still work when there is no ground. The NEC explicitly allows > >> them > >> to be installed when there is no ground, but in that case they have to > >> have the label several people have referred to. IMHO RBM's second post > >> is the best advice.
> >> -- > >> bud-- > >> - Hide quoted text -
> >> - Show quoted text -
> The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google > one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use > google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
> > far better to install a ground wire.
> > its not a killer expense
> Using your Ouija board again?
> You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. > And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a > water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
> -- > bud--- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -
most people overestimate the difficulty in fishing wires in walls.
>I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that >doesn't.
Nope. As mentioned several times in this thread, GFCI's work just fine without a ground. In most cases, they are a safe and code approved alternative to installing a safety ground. -- Doug
> most people overestimate the difficulty in fishing wires in walls.
> So, you've polled "most people" have you???- Hide quoted text -
theres often a easy way to get a wire to where you want it.
too many get scared off by just the idea of running a wire. personally i enjoy the challenge of wall fishing. have done a good bit of it over the years.
a un grounded GFCI will cause home inspection grief...........
On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 08:51:11 -0500, Nate Nagel <njna...@roosters.net> wrote: >I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that >doesn't.
On Nov 3, 10:28 pm, AZ Nomad <aznoma...@PremoveOBthisOX.COM> wrote:
> On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 08:51:11 -0500, Nate Nagel <njna...@roosters.net> wrote: > >I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that > >doesn't.
> Exactly wrong.
Well you can have trooubles depending on what you plug in. some devices REQUIRE a ground for proper operation.
computers, fluroscent lamps, come quickly to mind..........
> On Nov 2, 9:34 pm, DD_BobK <rkaza...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > On Nov 2, 6:02 pm, Lee B <not_my_real_a...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> > > gfretw...@aol.com wrote: > > > > On Mon, 2 Nov 2009 19:05:39 -0500, "cshenk" <cshe...@cox.net> wrote:
> > > >> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> > > > Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > > > > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
> > > That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few > > > short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly > > > less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 > > > others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 > > > block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not > > > living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble > > > over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace > > > some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's > > > asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and > > > will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the > > > originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
> > > BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there > > > before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a > > > ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water > > > pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be > > > some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they > > > want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
> > Lee-
> > Fix the easy / cheap ones.
> > The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson; turn off the > > power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. > > Running a ground wire to the nearest water pipe is pretty much a hack > > solution. My suggestion; if no ground at box, install & "sticker" the > > GFI.
> > Negotiate some dollars to be held in the escrow acct to pay for some > > of the disputed items (chimney waterproofing & sidewalk > > removal) ...don't want to be fixing the laundry list prior to sale & > > have the buyer back out.
> > cheers > > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> > - Show quoted text -
> re: "The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent person; turn off > the power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. "
> That's assuming the GFCI fits in the original box. My house was built > in '56 and getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was > either difficult or impossible. >>>>getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was either difficult or impossible.<<<<<<<<
........and a reasonably competent person would be able to figure this out.
btw some of the currently available GFI's are a bit smaller than first generation GFI's and are an easier install
getting first generation GFI's into (1980) metal "old work" was tough but doable
> > > > >> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> > > > > Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > > > > > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
> > > > That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few > > > > short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly > > > > less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 > > > > others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 > > > > block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not > > > > living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble > > > > over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace > > > > some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's > > > > asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and > > > > will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the > > > > originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
> > > > BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there > > > > before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a > > > > ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water > > > > pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be > > > > some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they > > > > want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
> > > Lee-
> > > Fix the easy / cheap ones.
> > > The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson; turn off the > > > power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. > > > Running a ground wire to the nearest water pipe is pretty much a hack > > > solution. My suggestion; if no ground at box, install & "sticker" the > > > GFI.
> > > Negotiate some dollars to be held in the escrow acct to pay for some > > > of the disputed items (chimney waterproofing & sidewalk > > > removal) ...don't want to be fixing the laundry list prior to sale & > > > have the buyer back out.
> > > cheers > > > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> > > - Show quoted text -
> > re: "The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent person; turn off > > the power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. "
> > That's assuming the GFCI fits in the original box. My house was built > > in '56 and getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was > > either difficult or impossible. > >>>>getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was either difficult or impossible.<<<<<<<<
> ........and a reasonably competent person would be able to figure this > out.
> btw some of the currently available GFI's are a bit smaller than > first generation GFI's and are an easier install
> getting first generation GFI's into (1980) metal "old work" was tough > but doable
> cheers > Bob
> cheers > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> - Show quoted text -
re: "...and a reasonably competent person would be able to figure this out."
Right, except that you never mentioned that in your earlier post.
You listed the steps required to swap it, without any caveats, which is why I brought it up.
Keep in mind that the OP also mentioned a receptacle in a medicine cupboard, which also might present an space problem.
On Tue, 3 Nov 2009 20:18:57 -0800 (PST), hall...@aol.com <hall...@aol.com> wrote: >On Nov 3, 10:28???pm, AZ Nomad <aznoma...@PremoveOBthisOX.COM> wrote: >> On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 08:51:11 -0500, Nate Nagel <njna...@roosters.net> wrote: >> >I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that >> >doesn't.
>> Exactly wrong. >Well you can have trooubles depending on what you plug in. some >devices REQUIRE a ground for proper operation. >computers, fluroscent lamps, come quickly to mind..........
all will work perfectly without a ground. keep trying.
The ground is there for equipment operation. It's there to safeguard the human during a electrical fault (110 breaks loose, touches the case; transformer isolation breaks down, etc.)
On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 08:11:25 -0600, AZ Nomad <aznoma...@PremoveOBthisOX.COM> wrote: >On Tue, 3 Nov 2009 20:18:57 -0800 (PST), hall...@aol.com <hall...@aol.com> wrote: >>On Nov 3, 10:28???pm, AZ Nomad <aznoma...@PremoveOBthisOX.COM> wrote: >>> On Tue, 03 Nov 2009 08:51:11 -0500, Nate Nagel <njna...@roosters.net> wrote: >>> >I believe the GFCI itself needs a ground, it's the stuff downstream that >>> >doesn't.
>>> Exactly wrong. >>Well you can have trooubles depending on what you plug in. some >>devices REQUIRE a ground for proper operation. >>computers, fluroscent lamps, come quickly to mind.......... >all will work perfectly without a ground. keep trying. >The ground is there for equipment operation. It's there to safeguard the human >during a electrical fault (110 breaks loose, touches the case; transformer >isolation breaks down, etc.)
god damn keyboard dyslexia. That should read: "The ground is NOT there for equipment operation."
On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 09:13:26 -0500, sa...@dog.com <sa...@dog.com> wrote: >Most "computer repairmen" are not really electronic techs. They are >amateur parts changers who turned a hobby into a job. That is evident >in your friend's diagnosis. There is no scientific basis for the claim >that personal computers need a ground to operate properly. That has >been true since the inception of personal computers. A good ground is >a good idea, but not to make the computer free from "static issues" or >to enhance reliability.
You don't need a ground to avoid "static issues" either.
Static electricity is when two objects are at different electrical potentials. Connect them together and there is a brief electrical current until they are at equal potentials.
When installing static sensative devices into a computer, one doesn't need to be grounded. One simply needs to be at the same static potential as the equipment. For example, after removing a memory module from its antistatic wrapping, hold it in one hand, with the other touch the computer's case. Module, human, and computer are now all at the same static potential and there will not be a equipment damaging current flow when the device is installed.
I live in bone dry phoenix arizona and have to do something like this every time I kiss my wife goodbye before going to work. I touch her hand first so the static zap is there instead of at the kiss.
sa...@dog.com wrote: > Most "computer repairmen" are not really electronic techs. They are > amateur parts changers who turned a hobby into a job. That is evident > in your friend's diagnosis. There is no scientific basis for the claim > that personal computers need a ground to operate properly. That has > been true since the inception of personal computers. A good ground is > a good idea, but not to make the computer free from "static issues" or > to enhance reliability.
A ground might be necessary for some surge protectors to work. The computer that's plugged into it, not so much.
On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 08:44:44 -0600, zxcvbob <zxcv...@charter.net> wrote: >sa...@dog.com wrote: >> Most "computer repairmen" are not really electronic techs. They are >> amateur parts changers who turned a hobby into a job. That is evident >> in your friend's diagnosis. There is no scientific basis for the claim >> that personal computers need a ground to operate properly. That has >> been true since the inception of personal computers. A good ground is >> a good idea, but not to make the computer free from "static issues" or >> to enhance reliability.
>A ground might be necessary for some surge protectors to work. The >computer that's plugged into it, not so much.
Nope. If the surge protector's ground input is isolated, they'll still work perfectly.
On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 09:48:31 -0500, sa...@dog.com <sa...@dog.com> wrote: >On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 08:32:59 -0600, AZ Nomad ><aznoma...@PremoveOBthisOX.COM> wrote: >>On Wed, 04 Nov 2009 09:13:26 -0500, sa...@dog.com <sa...@dog.com> wrote: >>>Most "computer repairmen" are not really electronic techs. They are >>>amateur parts changers who turned a hobby into a job. That is evident >>>in your friend's diagnosis. There is no scientific basis for the claim >>>that personal computers need a ground to operate properly. That has >>>been true since the inception of personal computers. A good ground is >>>a good idea, but not to make the computer free from "static issues" or >>>to enhance reliability.
>>You don't need a ground to avoid "static issues" either.
> > > > > >> Look, houses sell all the time 'as is'.
> > > > > > Not so much this year. You have to make yours look better than the 10 > > > > > > others the realtor is showing the buyer today.
> > > > > That is certainly true in my neighborhood. There are still quite a few > > > > > short sales and foreclosures, all of which are listed for significantly > > > > > less as-is than the other houses for sale. And there are at least 2-3 > > > > > others identical to mine (1950's end of group row house)within about a 4 > > > > > block radius. , and even more that are inside groups. And since I'm not > > > > > living there, and am juggling two mortgages, I'm not going to quibble > > > > > over too much! (Well except for the part where they want me to replace > > > > > some cracked tiles on the bathroom wall. My contractor said that's > > > > > asking for problems, that it'll go from 8 tiles to their neighbors and > > > > > will end up with a bunch of tiles, none of which will match the > > > > > originals. OTOH, the buyer didn't specify they have to match!)
> > > > > BTW, called an electrician from a company that had done work there > > > > > before. He quoted $125 over the phone. He'll check to see if there is a > > > > > ground. If not he also mentioned that it could be attached to the water > > > > > pipe. Thanks for the help. It was such a relief to hear it would not be > > > > > some thousand dollar type of repair! Onward and upward to where they > > > > > want an unused sidewalk removed. And the chimney waterproofed.
> > > > Lee-
> > > > Fix the easy / cheap ones.
> > > > The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson; turn off the > > > > power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. > > > > Running a ground wire to the nearest water pipe is pretty much a hack > > > > solution. My suggestion; if no ground at box, install & "sticker" the > > > > GFI.
> > > > Negotiate some dollars to be held in the escrow acct to pay for some > > > > of the disputed items (chimney waterproofing & sidewalk > > > > removal) ...don't want to be fixing the laundry list prior to sale & > > > > have the buyer back out.
> > > > cheers > > > > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> > > > - Show quoted text -
> > > re: "The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent person; turn off > > > the power to the receptacle & swap if for a GFI recepetacle. "
> > > That's assuming the GFCI fits in the original box. My house was built > > > in '56 and getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was > > > either difficult or impossible. > > >>>>getting GFCI's into some of the original work boxes was either difficult or impossible.<<<<<<<<
> > ........and a reasonably competent person would be able to figure this > > out.
> > btw some of the currently available GFI's are a bit smaller than > > first generation GFI's and are an easier install
> > getting first generation GFI's into (1980) metal "old work" was tough > > but doable
> > cheers > > Bob
> > cheers > > Bob- Hide quoted text -
> > - Show quoted text -
> re: "...and a reasonably competent person would be able to figure this > out."
> Right, except that you never mentioned that in your earlier post.
> You listed the steps required to swap it, without any caveats, which > is why I brought it up.
It was there...just had a couple typos
>>>>The GFI can be done by a reasonable competent preson;<<<
DD_BobK wrote: >> The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google >> one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use >> google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
>>> far better to install a ground wire. >>> its not a killer expense >> Using your Ouija board again?
>> You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. >> And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a >> water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
>> -- >> bud--
> And the reason your previously posted replies contained lots of > "quoted text" that you failed to "edit" ...might be?
> Editing is too difficult a concept?
Could be equally applied to hallerb.
On the other had you cleverly edited out the context for my reply and left parts that are not relevant. Editing is too difficult a concept?
In any case, at least leaving "too much" gives the context for how the thread got where it is.
The relics inserted by the google "newsreader" are garbage. They are 100% noise. When I use google I carefully edit them out.
> DD_BobK wrote: > >> The only newsreader that leaves this garbage is your retarded google > >> one. The garbage is just more noise, even to the people that use > >> google-groups. Editing is too difficult a concept?
> >>> far better to install a ground wire. > >>> its not a killer expense > >> Using your Ouija board again?
> >> You have no idea how difficult it will be to add a ground wire. > >> And it has not been code compliant for many years to attach it to a > >> water pipe, except for the first 5 feet of pipe inside the building.
> >> -- > >> bud--
> > And the reason your previously posted replies contained lots of > > "quoted text" that you failed to "edit" ...might be?
> > Editing is too difficult a concept?
> Could be equally applied to hallerb.
> On the other had you cleverly edited out the context for my reply and > left parts that are not relevant. > Editing is too difficult a concept?
> In any case, at least leaving "too much" gives the context for how the > thread got where it is.
> The relics inserted by the google "newsreader" are garbage. They are > 100% noise. When I use google I carefully edit them out.
> -- > bud--
Sorry my editing didn't meet your specs....too little, too much, too selective........ too bad
In the future, I'll continue to post the way I want to post...welcome to the internet.
If you need help using navigation means on your computer maybe someone can help you out.
Don't like a post...here's a tip.....ignore, don't read it.